A tiny brown mushroom collected in a central Florida wetland has turned out to be the first fungus known to make two very different families of compounds: psilocybin, the psychedelic in so-called magic mushrooms, and amatoxins, the poisons behind most fatal mushroom poisonings. Researchers at the University of Florida Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences (UF/IFAS) described the species, Galerina indica, in a paper published November 11 in the journal Current Biology, and they have given it a fitting nickname: the "dark magic mushroom."
Until now, mycologists had found psilocybin in some groups of fungi and amatoxins in others, but never both in a single species. The team says the finding is as much a public-safety lesson as a scientific curiosity.
The discovery started with a survey of Galerina, a large genus of more than 300 species, several of which were already known to carry amatoxins. The researchers wanted to know whether any Florida species carried those toxins too. Andrew Kunik, then a student researcher in the lab of plant pathology professor Matthew E. Smith, spotted the specimens at the UF/IFAS Ordway Swisher Biological Station, growing on a decaying, moss-covered palm trunk.
Something about them did not fit. Besides belonging to a genus linked to amatoxins, the mushroom stained blue when handled, a trait seen in some psilocybin-producing species. Kunik handled the genome and bioinformatics work while UF chemist Michael Christopher ran the chemical analysis, and the two results lined up: the mushroom contained both compound families. The chemistry also turned up a form of amatoxin that had not been documented before.
The wider team included Ben Lemmond of the Smith lab, additional UF chemists, Bryn Dentinger of the University of Utah and Jason Slot of Ohio State University. The survey also identified a second Galerina species that makes psilocybin without amatoxins, and a third that makes neither.
Genetic comparisons suggest Galerina indica did not invent its psilocybin machinery on its own. The researchers found that its psilocybin genes share an origin with those in unrelated psychedelic fungi, pointing to horizontal gene transfer, in which genetic material moves between species rather than from parent to offspring. Smith has estimated that the transfer may date back roughly 15.5 million years.
Why a mushroom would carry both compounds remains unclear. Kunik has noted that scientists still do not fully understand why fungi make psilocybin at all, and that the ecological role of amatoxins is also unsettled, though they may deter animals that eat mushrooms. One idea the team has raised is that carrying two very different chemical defenses could make the species harder for predators to adapt to, but that remains a hypothesis. Future experiments that switch off the genes for one compound or the other could help answer it.
Smith, who also serves as Florida's state mycologist, regularly helps Florida Poison Control, emergency physicians and veterinarians identify mushrooms that people or pets may have eaten. He has stressed that these mushrooms are small, brown and easy to confuse with hundreds of other species, even for trained experts. The discovery underlines a basic rule: a mushroom's appearance, including blue bruising, is not a reliable guide to what it contains or whether it is safe. Psilocybin also remains a Schedule I controlled substance under federal law and is illegal in Florida.
Anyone worried that a person or pet has eaten a wild mushroom should contact poison control or a medical professional right away rather than wait for symptoms.
For people who simply love cooking with fungi, Florida has a growing number of cultivated mushroom farms. Growers on Pscilly such as Sunrise Harvest Mushroom Farm in Crystal River, Florida Shroom King Mushroom Farm in Orlando and South Florida Fungi in Miami produce culinary and functional mushrooms under controlled conditions, a far safer route to fresh mushrooms than guessing in the woods.
Kunik, who is now a postbaccalaureate researcher at Harvard, has said the find shows how small, unremarkable-looking fungi can hide chemistry scientists are only beginning to understand.