Pscilly

Canadian Mushroom Tariffs: U.S. Trade Panel Hears Final Arguments

By · Published

The fight over Canadian mushrooms on American grocery shelves has reached its last round. On Nov. 17, the U.S. International Trade Commission held its final public hearing on whether imports of fresh mushrooms from Canada have hurt U.S. growers. The commission's answer, due next month, will decide whether duties on those imports become permanent.

How the case got here

The case began with a petition from the Fresh Mushrooms Fair Trade Coalition, a group of domestic growers and packers that includes Giorgio Fresh Co. and Giorgi Mushroom Co. The U.S. Department of Commerce opened antidumping and countervailing duty investigations in January 2026. Antidumping duties target goods sold below what the government calculates as fair value. Countervailing duties offset government subsidies.

Commerce has already issued preliminary findings against Canadian producers on both counts. In May it set preliminary countervailing duty rates of 1.62% to 4.97%, depending on the producer, and those duties took effect May 18. In July it announced preliminary antidumping margins of 2.00% to 11.80% for individually examined companies, with an 8.26% rate for all other Canadian producers and exporters. The trade commission made its own preliminary finding in January that there was a reasonable indication of injury to the U.S. industry.

What the U.S. growers say

The coalition called this week's hearing a step toward restoring fair trade in the U.S. mushroom market. Mark Currie, CEO of the food division of The Giorgi Companies, said the investigations showed Canadian producers were selling below cost while receiving government subsidies, and he rejected the argument that the dispute is about Canadian farms modernizing.

Other coalition members put the case in terms of investment. Pat Jurgensmeyer, president of J-M Farms in Miami, Oklahoma, said the duties protect what American growers have built over generations. CJ Ciarrocchi, who leads a coalition member farm in Chester County, Pennsylvania, said retailers rely on a strong domestic supply chain and that relief from imports would let growers keep investing.

What Canadian growers say

Mushrooms Canada, the national trade association for Canadian growers based in Harriston, Ontario, has disputed the case from the start. When the preliminary antidumping rates came out, executive vice-president and CEO Ryan Koeslag said they showed the petitioner's original allegations were overstated. The petition had alleged dumping margins of 32% to 44%, far above what Commerce found.

Koeslag argued that the finding reflects technical calculation rules in U.S. trade law rather than market reality. He said a direct comparison of average U.S. and Canadian prices would show no dumping. The association has also warned that added costs would end up being passed on to shoppers, and it has stressed how closely the two countries' mushroom industries are tied through cross-border supply. Canada's federal government has said it will keep defending Canadian programs and growers in the investigations.

What happens next

Two decisions remain. Commerce is expected to announce final antidumping and countervailing duty rates in early December. The trade commission has scheduled its final vote for Dec. 18. If both agencies rule in favor of the U.S. growers, Commerce will issue formal duty orders on fresh mushrooms from Canada. If the commission finds no injury or threat of injury, the duties end.

Why it matters locally

Chester County, home to Kennett Square and its "Mushroom Capital of the World" nickname, sits at the center of the U.S. side of this dispute. Shoppers who buy from growers there, including Phillips Mushroom Farms, or from city specialty growers such as Mycopolitan Mushrooms in Philadelphia, are part of the market both sides are fighting over. Neither business is a named party in the case. Any change in duties is most likely to show up in the price and supply of everyday white and brown mushrooms in grocery stores and restaurants.

Preliminary U.S. duty rates on fresh mushrooms from Canada
Countervailing duty, low1.62 %
Countervailing duty, high4.97 %
Antidumping, low2 %
Antidumping, all others8.26 %
Antidumping, high11.8 %
Alleged in petition, low32 %
Alleged in petition, high44 %

Preliminary rates from the U.S. Department of Commerce (May and July 2026); petitioner's alleged margins shown for comparison. Final rates are expected in December.

On Pscilly

Published
November 19, 2026